ICSE 2001 Workshop on "SE over the Internet"

Review form

------------------------------------------------

Review form Part 1 (This part will not be transmitted to the authors)

Reviewer:    Charles Petrie

Comments for program committee:
Novel approach that should be discussed in a workshop.

------------------------------------------------

Review Form Part 2  (This part will be transmitted to the authors)

Paper number: 8
Title: Providing Software Engineering
Services for Virtual Software Organizations (Work in Progress)
Authors: Frank Maurer, Jeremiah Wittewrongel

Please rate 3 aspects of the paper using the following scheme:
5= Excellent, 4 = Good, 3 = Fair, 2 = Poor, 1 = Very poor

Relevance for workshop       5
Originality   4
Results        1    

Please recommend if the paper should be accepted for presentation at the workshop 
(Accept, Don't know, Reject)
Accept

General comments for the authors: 
What is good, what is bad in the paper? 

Good: very novel and could be a major new service. Obviously
well thought-out. Could be very important.
Bad: no results yet, but early work suitable for a workshop
Not clear that this is academic research from abstract.